When it comes to the fire compartmentation of a building, two solutions often come up in discussions with designers and clients: fire curtains and fire doors. Although both share the same basic purpose — to stop the spread of fire and smoke — they are designed for completely different situations. The wrong choice can mean extra costs, non-compliance with regulations or, in the worst case, a system that fails at the critical moment.

What are they and how do they work?

🚪 Fire Doors

Fire doors are fixed building elements, permanently installed in wall or floor openings. They are classified by fire resistance in minutes: EI 30, EI 60, EI 90 or even more. They can be single-leaf, double-leaf, sliding or pivoting.

  • They work passively — they stay closed permanently or close automatically when smoke/heat is detected
  • They need a specifically sized wall opening (they cannot be installed just anywhere)
  • They allow people and equipment to pass through an active opening
  • They are the standard solution for corridors, escape stairs and access to technical areas
  • Certified to EN 16034 and EN 1634

🪟 Fire Curtains

Fire curtains are mechanical systems that deploy automatically from a ceiling-mounted housing, creating a vertical protective barrier in large openings (shop fronts, atriums, architectural openings). They are activated by detection systems or sprinklers.

  • They work actively — they deploy automatically in a fire and stay out of sight the rest of the time
  • They can cover very large openings (tens of metres wide) without intermediate columns
  • They allow architectural flexibility — the space stays open under normal conditions
  • Classified EW or EI (radiation barrier / integrity + insulation)
  • Certified to EN 16034 and EN 13241

Direct Comparison

  • Small openings: 0.9 m – 2.5 m wide
  • Lower initial cost
  • Simple, standard installation
  • Need periodic maintenance of hinges, seals and closing devices
  • Permanently visible — aesthetic impact in premium spaces
  • Can be forced open or blocked by mistake
  • Ideal for: corridors, stairs, technical access
Fire Curtains
  • Large openings: 3 m – 30+ m wide
  • Higher initial cost, but justified for large openings
  • Need space in the ceiling for the housing
  • Maintenance: annual testing of the mechanism and motor
  • Invisible when not activated — superior aesthetics
  • Reliable automatic activation, independent of the human factor
  • Ideal for: atriums, shopping centres, industrial halls, open-plan office buildings

Clear Advantages and Limitations

Fire Doors — Advantages

  • ✓ A proven solution, easy to source and install
  • ✓ Low cost for standard openings
  • ✓ Available in many versions (timber, steel, fire-rated glass)
  • ✓ Need no power supply (spring/mechanical closing versions)
  • ✓ Easy to replace or upgrade

Fire Doors — Limitations

  • ✗ Impossible to install in openings wider than ~3 m
  • ✗ Need a solid wall frame — they do not work in open-plan structures
  • ✗ Can be illegally held open (risk of non-compliance)
  • ✗ Permanent visual impact in spaces with open architecture

Fire Curtains — Advantages

  • ✓ Cover large openings without intermediate columns or walls
  • ✓ 100% automatic activation, with no human intervention
  • ✓ Invisible in normal use
  • ✓ Allow complete freedom in architectural design
  • ✓ Some models allow people to escape under the curtain (partial descent)

Fire Curtains — Limitations

  • ✗ Significantly higher initial cost
  • ✗ Need to be integrated with the building’s fire detection system
  • ✗ Space needed in the ceiling/floor for the housing (minimum 200–400 mm)
  • ✗ Mandatory periodic maintenance of electromechanical components

When to choose which solution? — Practical Scenarios

The right decision depends on several factors: the size of the opening, the type of building, regulatory requirements and the budget. Here are some typical scenarios:

1
Escape corridor or stairwell in an apartment or office building

→ An EI 60 fire door is the standard solution. The opening is max. 1–1.5 m, and regulations require self-closing doors on escape routes.

2
Open atrium in a shopping centre or premium office building

→ An EW or EI fire curtain is the only viable solution. An 8–20 m opening cannot be compartmented with doors without destroying the architectural concept.

3
Industrial hall with continuous production flow

→ A fire curtain lets machinery and people pass without permanent physical obstacles. It is activated only in the event of a fire.

4
Access to a server room or technical room

→ An EI 60 or EI 90 fire door, usually with a fire-rated glass panel for visibility. A standard opening does not justify the cost of a curtain.

5
Underground car park with access to the building

→ A fire curtain or fire door depending on the width of the ramp. If the access is for vehicles (>3 m), a fire curtain is mandatory. For pedestrians, a door is sufficient.

6
Refurbishment of an existing building with a low false ceiling

→ A fire door if there is not enough space in the ceiling for the curtain housing (min. 200–400 mm). The designer must check feasibility before specifying.

Quick Decision Table

Criterion Recommendation Solution
Openings under 2.5 m wide Economical, compliant solution Fire door
Openings over 3 m wide A door is not technically feasible Fire curtain
Uninterrupted flow of people/machinery Active barrier, not a permanent one Fire curtain
Mandatory escape route (regulation) Required fire safety standard Fire door
Premium aesthetic space (atrium, showroom) No permanent visual impact Fire curtain
Limited budget, standard openings Best cost/performance ratio Fire door
No space in the ceiling for the housing Structural constraint Fire door
Building with an integrated fire detection system Automatic activation available Fire curtain

What do Romanian regulations say?

Both fire doors and fire curtains are regulated by European and Romanian standards. Here is what you need to know:

📋 Regulations applicable in Romania

  • P 118/1-2018 — Fire safety regulation for buildings, Part I (updated)
  • SR EN 16034:2014 — European standard for doors and windows with fire resistance and/or smoke control characteristics
  • SR EN 1634-1 — Fire resistance tests for door and shutter assemblies
  • SR EN 13241 — Industrial, commercial, garage doors and gates
  • Decision no. 305/2011 (CPR) — European Construction Products Regulation (CE marking mandatory)

Both types of product require CE marking and a Declaration of Performance (DoP). Installation must be carried out by authorised companies, and the products must match exactly the fire resistance class specified in the technical design. There are no “universal” solutions — each product is certified for a specific type of installation and specified dimensions.

An often overlooked aspect: periodic maintenance is a legal requirement. Fire doors must be inspected every year (seals, self-closing devices, hinges), and fire curtains need an annual functional test and a check of the electronic activation system.

⚠️ Common mistakes we see in projects

  • Specifying a fire door for 4–5 m openings — there is no standard construction solution; a curtain is mandatory
  • Installing a curtain without integrating it with the detection system — the curtain is useless if it does not receive an activation signal
  • Replacing a fire door with an uncertified one — this invalidates the compartmentation and leads to ISU penalties
  • Ignoring the ceiling space — the curtain housing needs 200–400 mm above the false ceiling, a dimension often checked too late in the project
  • Neglecting maintenance — a fire door with a damaged seal no longer provides smoke tightness and loses its EI certification

Conclusion: there is no “better” solution — there is the right solution for your situation

Fire curtains and fire doors are not in competition — they complement each other. In a complex building you will find both, each in its proper place. The right decision is made at the design stage, together with a fire protection specialist, who will assess:

  • The dimensions and geometry of the compartmentation openings
  • The use of the space and its traffic flows
  • The fire resistance class required by regulations
  • The structural and architectural constraints of the building
  • The investment budget and long-term maintenance costs
  • Integration with the existing fire detection and alarm systems

Fire Stopping Engineering SRL carries out both fire door installation, and fire curtain installation, offering solutions that comply with current regulations, with a guarantee and full certification.

Do you need fire curtains for your project?

Our team of specialists can offer you a free assessment and a tailored quote, adapted to your technical requirements and available budget.

◆ See our Fire Curtains service →